On a recent trip to Washington DC, we chose to stay in Alexandria Virginia. Our hotel was located just steps away from the very upscale office campus depicted in the picture below.
It turns out that this 2 million square foot, 4 building complex is the home of the US Patent and Trademark offices, and houses fewer than 10,000 employees. Really?
When someone says patents to me, I picture some old building, smelling of 200 year old paper, with an inspector wearing a visor and coke-bottle eyeglasses, who makes marks with a pencil, and has a big stack of applications in front of him.
Obviously I am truly disconnected from reality.
At the end of 2009, there were 6,242 patent examiners in this complex. The office grants approximately 150,000 patents per year. Now, if my geriatric, bespectacled examiner was the one processing the paperwork, I would be impressed, but again, I am wrenched from my hopeful world view to the realization that each patent examiner ends up granting a patent once every 2 weeks. Each examiner averages less than 26 patents a year.
In this day of modernization, it's ludicrous to me that our tax dollars would support the inefficiencies of an organization like this. Two weeks to process a patent? Seems to me that a person with an above average IQ could do a few LexisNexis searches and a bit of googling to determine the validity of an application. But perhaps slow and steady wins the race, and protects the integrity of the patents granted?
Nope
Some of the patents granted by this slow moving group of comfortably lodged employees include the following examples cited in
Wikipedia:
- U.S. Patent 5,443,036, "Method of exercising a cat", covers having a cat chase the beam from a laser pointer. The patent has been criticized as being obvious.
- U.S. Patent 6,025,810, "Hyper-light-speed antenna", an antenna that sends signals faster than the speed of light.
- U.S. Patent 6,368,227, "Method of swinging on a swing", issued April 9, 2002, was granted to a seven-year old boy, whose father, a patent attorney, wanted to demonstrate how the patent system worked to his son (aged 5 at the time of the application).
- U.S. Patent 6,960,975, "Space vehicle propelled by the pressure of inflationary vacuum state", describes an anti-gravity device and a perpetual motion machine.
If this organization were in private hands, and the cost of processing patents was exclusively borne by the applicants, there is no way that production of 1 patent every 2 weeks per examiner would be tolerated, let alone issuing a patent that describes how to exercise a cat with a laser pointer.
This is the type of government agency run amok that needs to be reigned in.